Minorities in Oregon Less Likely to Get Emergency Pain Care
/By Pat Anson, PNN Editor
Oregon’s treatment of chronic pain patients came under fire this year when state health officials drafted a controversial plan to forcibly taper thousands of Medicaid patients on long-term opioid therapy. The proposal was scaled back after nationwide criticism from patient advocates and pain management experts, who said it would “exacerbate suffering for thousands of patients.”
Minorities in Oregon needing emergency treatment for pain may also be suffering unnecessarily, according to a new study by Portland State University researchers.
"We found evidence that the odds of receiving a lower quality of care from EMS providers are higher among racial minorities in Oregon, when compared to white patients in Oregon, after experiencing traumatic and painful injuries," said Jamie Kennel, a PhD student and lead author of the study published in the journal Medical Care.
PSU researchers analyzed nearly 26,000 health records of patients who received emergency care for traumatic injuries in Oregon between 2015 and 2017.
Only about one in five white patients received opioids or other types of pain medication from EMS responders in Oregon. But the odds were 32% lower for black patients, 24% lower for Asian patients and 21% lower for Latino patients. This was despite the fact that black and Latino patients reported higher average pain scores than white patients.
ODDS OF GETTING EMS PAIN MEDICATION
White Patients 20.1%
Latino Patients 17.2%
Asian Patients 14.2%
Black Patients 13.9%
"This is very large, concerning and should be motivating for change," said Kennel. "Like most healthcare providers, EMS providers don't desire to provide inequitable healthcare but often have never been exposed to evidence suggesting these disparities are taking place."
The researchers also found that Asian and Latino patients were less likely to have their pain assessed – a simple procedure in which patients are asked to rate their pain on a scale of zero to 10.
While previous studies have found racial and ethnic disparities in medical care, this was the first to look at both pain assessment and pain medication during emergency care in a large statewide database. Researchers did not look at what caused the inequities in pain treatment, but speculated that racial stereotypes and difficulty in communicating with patients with limited English played a role.
“Although it has been shown conclusively that there are no medically significant biological differences between individuals of different races/ethnicities, there is evidence that medical providers nevertheless believe race/ethnicity to be a medically relevant factor and may be adjusting their clinical actions accordingly,” researchers concluded.
"We hope that, when exposed to this new evidence, individual EMS providers will work with their agencies to better understand, and take steps to mitigate, this phenomenon in their community."
A large 2016 study found that black patients who visit hospital emergency rooms are significantly less likely to receive opioid prescriptions than white patients. Opioids were prescribed for blacks at about half the rate for whites with back and abdominal pain.
Another large study of VA patients found that African-Americans on long-term opioid therapy were more likely to be drug tested and significantly more likely to have their opioid prescriptions stopped if an illicit drug was detected.
