Banning Kratom is Foolish. Governments Should Avoid Hysteria

By Crystal Lindell

I always say the way you know that kratom is among the rare herbal supplements that actually relieves pain is that everyone is always trying to ban it. 

Unfortunately, two towns in my state - Illinois - have done just that. City councils in Marion and Herrin voted this week to ban the sale and delivery of kratom. 

The reported justifications for the bans are naive at best and outright dishonest at worst. 

According to an article about the bans, the Marion city council acted after hearing from the widow of 41-year old Blake Pieroni, who died two months ago. She blames kratom for his death.

“He initially believed, as many do, that kratom was a safe natural supplement,” said Emily Pieroni. “The first time he tried kratom was when the owner of a gas station here in Marion offered Blake kratom as an energy shot. He told him it was like a 5-Hour Energy, but safer and more natural.”

I was especially interested in this anecdote because it would indeed be quite noteworthy if kratom alone had directly caused someone's death. Such cases are incredibly rare. However, when I looked into it, I quickly found that this was not the case. 

In fact, Emily Pieroni has written publicly that her husband died by suicide. She even includes this information in her Change.org petition asking for kratom to be banned:

“At first, it seemed harmless — just a boost of energy. But it quickly became an addiction. He tried to quit three times in seven months. The withdrawal was unbearable. Eventually, the emotional toll was too much, and kratom addiction led my husband to take his own life.”

Someone committing suicide is not the same thing as someone accidentally overdosing on a substance. If her husband had been trying to avoid coffee when he died, would that be enough to blame caffeine for his death? No. 

While I’m sympathetic to the immense grief Emily Pieroni is no doubt going through, especially as someone who has lost a loved one to suicide myself, her advocacy to have kratom banned is going to cause more harm. 

In fact, it is because she is still dealing with such raw grief that the Marion and Herrin city councils should have acted with clearer heads. 

Instead, they embraced kratom hysteria, with Marion Mayor Mike Absher even calling it “gas station heroin.” 

I want to be very clear here: Kratom is not gas station heroin. It’s an incredibly mild supplement similar to coffee. In fact, kratom comes from the leaves of the Mitragyna speciosa tree, which is literally part of the coffee family.

I could also call coffee “gas station meth” but that doesn’t make it true. And it would actually be more accurate to describe kratom as “herbal coffee.”

Because in reality, kratom helps countless people, including me. I have taken kratom for years for chronic pain. It is the only thing sold over the counter that actually helps me. 

For me, kratom withdrawal symptoms are as mild as withdrawing from coffee. Yes, some people may struggle to stop drinking coffee completely, but we as a society have decided that does not mean coffee should be illegal.

I also want to note that the Herrin city ordinance bans “possession” specifically, which means police can now use it to cite or even arrest people who bought kratom elsewhere, ensnaring them in the legal system and all its ill effects. 

Many kratom users are just people with chronic pain or other health issues looking for relief. We should let them use kratom in peace. Kratom is legal in most states and the vast majority of people use it safely. About 100 deaths have been linked to kratom use, but other drugs and illicit substances were usually involved. 

I hope that other towns and municipalities considering kratom bans will also consider the immense harm those bans will cause. 

Kratom is a very mild alternative to other drugs that treat chronic pain and other health issues. That should be celebrated, not demonized. 

Instead of trying to falsely claim that kratom is the same as heroin, we should be lauding the fact that it’s nowhere near as strong as heroin, and yet it is still quite effective at treating pain.