By Roger Chriss, Columnist
The book “Unbroken Brain: A Revolutionary New Way of Understanding Addiction” by Maia Szalavitz offers invaluable insights about addiction. Her key point is that addiction should be seen as a learning disorder -- not a moral failing or brain disease.
Szalavitz says addiction treatment and drug policy should meet addicts where they are and deal with their reality, instead of using the moralistic or legalistic framework commonly seen in the opioid crisis.
Throughout the book, Szalavitz shares her own experiences with drug use in a way that does not mythologize addiction or recovery. Instead, her personal history highlights that there is no such thing as a typical addict and that addiction is not simply a moral failing or choice.
Szalavitz explains that addiction results from a complex combination of a person’s genetic makeup, early life experiences, and socio-cultural situation. Specifically, she states that: "There are three critical elements to it; the behavior has a psychological purpose; the specific learning pathways involved make it become nearly automatic and compulsive; and it doesn’t stop when it is no longer adaptive.”
She likens addiction to dysfunctional self-medication, an effort to self-soothe and regulate internal states that have gone horribly wrong. This means that addiction is not about a substance, but about a person.
“Drugs alone do not ‘hijack the brain.’ Instead, what matters is what people learn -- both before and after trying them,” Szalavitz writes. “Addiction is, first and foremost, a relationship between a person and a substance, not an inevitable pharmacological reaction.”
Further, she states that “by itself, nothing is addictive; drugs can only be addictive in the context of set, setting, dose, dosing pattern, and numerous other personal, biological, and cultural variables.”
And there are several major risk factors for addiction, including severe early childhood trauma or abuse, existing mental illness, and serious life challenges. Particular emphasis is given to a history of abuse.
“In fact, one third to one half of heroin injectors have experienced sexual abuse, with the usual abuse rates for women who inject roughly double those for men. And in 50% of these sexual abuse cases, the offense was not just a single incident but an ongoing series of attacks, typically conducted by a relative or family friend who should have been a source of support, not stress,” wrote Szalavitz.
She also states that addiction is not just about euphoria: “Research now suggests that there are at least two distinct varieties of pleasure, which are chemically and psychologically quite different in terms of those effects on motivation. These types were originally characterized by psychiatrist Donald Klein as the ‘pleasure of the hunt’ and the ‘pleasure of the feast’.”
This means that addiction is about far more than just dopamine levels: “If dopamine is what creates the sense of pleasure, animals shouldn’t be able to enjoy food without it. Yet they do.”
Lower Risk of Addiction to Opioid Medication
On the subject of opioid medication, Szalavitz notes that about one in seven people do not tolerate opioids well enough to take them repeatedly and therefore have essentially no risk of opioid use disorder. Because of this and the importance of “set and setting” to addiction, she explains, “medical use of drugs carries a far lower risk of addiction than recreational use does.”
Because addiction involves a person in a particular sociocultural situation, she writes that “People with decent jobs, strong relationships, and good mental health rarely give that all up for intoxicating drugs; instead, drugs are powerful primarily when the rest of your life is broken.”
Approaches to addiction treatment that don't recognize the above are unlikely to succeed. Detox regimens, short-term medication therapy, and abstinence-only programs like Alcoholics Anonymous are generally inadequate. For instance, Szalavitz found a 2006 Cochrane Review that summarized the data plainly: “No experimental studies unequivocally demonstrated the effectiveness of AA.”
Instead, Szalavitz emphasizes the value of harm reduction, a process whose aim is to "meet the addicts where they are" and support them unconditionally, even if this means clean needle exchanges and safe injection sites.
“Don’t focus on whether getting high is morally or socially acceptable; recognize that people always have and probably always will take drugs and this doesn’t make them irrational or subhuman,” she wrote.
But American policy toward illegal drugs and attitudes toward medications with psychotropic effects are grounded in a moralistic view. “More generally, in the West, unearned pleasure has been labeled as sinful—the opposite of valued,” Szalavitz writes, explaining why any medication that helps a person feel good, or just not feel as bad, is viewed negatively. This has led to all manner of misguided policy in the War on Drugs.
“One of the sad ironies of our current drug policy is that the same treatment providers who have been cheerleaders for the war on drugs and who advocate the ongoing criminalization of drug use also claim to want to destigmatize ‘the disease of addiction’,” she wrote.
“This approach is doomed to failure because “punishment cannot solve a problem defined by its resistance to punishment.” Moreover, it is cruelly counterproductive because “the uniquely moral nature of the way we treat addicts as both sick and criminal also reinforces stigma.” By contrast, understanding addiction as a learning disorder leads to harm reduction as the core of a more effective approach to treatment.
“Unbroken Brain” is not pedantic or moralistic. Indeed, Szalavitz says that part of the reason U.S. policy toward drug addiction has failed is that it is pedantic and moralistic. But she also says that people who now say that addiction is a "brain disease" are missing the point too. "Drug exposure alone doesn't cause addiction," she says in the conclusion of the book.
A person's situation and circumstances matter a lot in drug use and addiction. And treatment requires recognizing that even the most addicted person can still learn and make positive changes in their life when given the chance.
Roger Chriss lives with Ehlers Danlos syndrome and is a proud member of the Ehlers-Danlos Society.
Roger is a technical consultant in Washington state, where he specializes in mathematics and research.
The information in this column should not be considered as professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. It is for informational purposes only and represents the author’s opinions alone. It does not inherently express or reflect the views, opinions and/or positions of Pain News Network.