Are Opioids or Economics Killing White Americans?

By Pat Anson, Editor

Opinions are all over the map about a recent study by two Princeton University researchers, who estimate that nearly half a million white Americans died in the last 15 years due to a quiet epidemic of pain, suicide, alcohol abuse and opioid overdoses.

The husband and wife research team of Angus Deaton and Anne Case were careful not to point a finger at any one cause, but speculated that financial stress caused by unemployment and stagnant incomes may be behind the rising mortality of middle-aged whites. The deaths were concentrated in baby boomers with a high school education or less.

But some were quick to blame the “opioid epidemic.”

“An opioid overdose epidemic is at the heart of this rise in white middle-age mortality,” wrote psychiatrist Richard Friedman, MD, in an editorial that appeared in the New York Times under the headline “How Doctors Helped Drive the Addiction Crisis.”

“Driving this opioid epidemic, in large part, is a disturbing change in the attitude within the medical profession about the use of these drugs to treat pain,” said Friedman. “It is physicians who, in large part, unleashed the current opioid epidemic with their promiscuous use of these drugs; we have a large responsibility to end it.”

And what should doctors do to end the epidemic?


Friedman said there was “strong evidence” that Motrin, Tylenol and other nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDS) were “safer and more effective for many painful conditions than opioid painkillers.”

The Fresno Bee took a more nuanced view of what it called “the epidemic of pain and heartbreak.”

“If ever a set of numbers cried out for deeper examination, it is this one. Human frailty may be epidemic, but surely it is also no surprise that a generation raised with the expectation of a secure future might sink into depression, hostility, illness, anguish and rage when that future fails to transpire,” The Bee said in an editorial. “Whether the solution is better jobs, cheaper schools, more mental health care or less reliance on painkillers, the distress of America’s white working class has become a public health crisis.”

“White Americans who used to be able to support a family are now struggling even in dual income households, and there's a corresponding loss in stature and self-esteem. They are turning to prescription opioids in greater numbers than minorities,” said the Baltimore Sun. “The transition to a 21st (century) economy is literally killing some people, and the United States can ill afford to ignore this disturbing development.”

Overseas news outlets also tended to blame the rising death rate on a “ruthless economy.”

“These people are dying because history has unexpectedly thrown them on the scrapheap,” said The Guardian. “White baby boomers had high expectations of the future, yet many of them have lived to discover that they will be worse off than their parents.”

“(The) findings should awaken Americans to the price we pay for pursuing economic policies that enrich the few at the expense of the many,” said David Cay Johnston in a column for Al Jezeera America. “The harsh reality is that our economy is in many ways stuck in 1998 and that for poorly educated Americans, the economy has become a living nightmare with no expectation of a brighter tomorrow. The rise in drug and alcohol poisonings as well as the rising tide of suicides should not surprise. But these trends should disturb.”

What do you think? Is the economy to blame for the increasing number of deaths? Or is it opioids?

Rheumatoid Arthritis Raises Death Risk

By Pat Anson, Editor

Rheumatoid arthritis (RA) is not only painful and disabling – new research indicates it raises the risk of an early death, especially for patients with seropositive RA.

In a study of nearly 1,000 women with RA, researchers at Brigham and Women’s Hospital (BWH) in Boston found that RA significantly increased the women’s risk of death from cardiovascular and respiratory disease. The women are enrolled in the Nurses' Health Study, which has followed more than 100,000 female registered nurses since 1976.

"Because the Nurses' Health Study is so large and has been following participants for so long, we were able to gather much more information about our subjects - we could follow them before and after diagnosis, take their health behaviors into account and determine specific causes of death. By doing so, we found strong evidence of increased risk for respiratory, cardiovascular and overall mortality for patients with RA," said lead author Jeffrey Sparks, MD, a physician in BWH's Division of Rheumatology, Immunology and Allergy.

RA is a chronic autoimmune disease in which the body’s own defenses attack joint tissues, causing swelling, inflammation and bone erosion. Because RA is incurable, treatments focus on suppressing the immune system to reduce inflammation and slow progression of the disease.

Sparks and his colleagues evaluated 964 women in the Nurses’ Health Study and compared their mortality rates to women in the study without RA. The team controlled for other risk factors, including smoking, a known cause of respiratory and cardiovascular mortality, as well as age, body mass index, physical activity and diet.

They found that RA was associated with a 40 percent increased risk of death and that many RA patients died of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).

Researchers also looked at differences between the two types of RA, "seropositive" and "seronegative." Patients with seropositive RA have auto-antibodies related to RA, and generally have more severe symptoms. The team found that participants with seropositive RA had nearly three times the risk of respiratory mortality than women who did not have RA. Seronegative RA was not significantly associated with increased risk of respiratory mortality.

"We found that whether participants with RA were seropositive or seronegative really mattered - those who were seropositive were at higher risk, particularly for respiratory mortality," said Sparks. "We hope that this study will encourage patients and clinicians to be more aware that patients with RA are at increased risk of both respiratory and cardiovascular mortality, particularly patients with seropositive RA."

A recent study by researchers in Mexico found that RA patients with no prior symptoms of heart disease were at higher risk of a heart attack. Their risk was higher even without other cardiovascular risk factors such as smoking and diabetes.

Many health experts believe the inflammation triggered by RA in the joints may cause inflammation throughout the body, including the heart’s coronary arteries.

According to the Arthritis Foundation, more than 50 percent of premature deaths in people with rheumatoid arthritis result from cardiovascular disease. The heightened risk of heart disease applies to all forms of arthritis, including osteoarthritis, gout, lupus and psoriatic arthritis.

Knee Osteoarthritis Raises Risk of Early Death

By Pat Anson, Editor

Osteoarthritis is painful no matter where it occurs – in the hip, fingers, elbow or other joints. But osteoarthritis of the knee seems to be particularly troublesome for middle-aged women. 

British researchers say knee osteoarthritis significantly raises the risk of cardiovascular disease and can even lead to early death.

In a study of early mortality in middle-aged women with osteoarthritis, researchers looked at data collected by the Chingford Study, which followed the health over 1,000 British middle-aged women for over two decades.

They found that osteoarthritis of the knee was strongly associated with early overall death and cardiovascular mortality. Women with knee pain and radiographic osteoarthritis had almost two times greater risk of early death and over three-times increased risk of dying from a cardiovascular event, when compared with women without knee pain or osteoarthritis. 

No link was found between hand osteoarthritis and a higher risk of mortality. 

“These findings suggest that any self-reported knee pain in osteoarthritis, as opposed to hand pain, seems to be a crucial factor leading to early cardiovascular mortality and is likely to be linked with decreased mobility. Radiographic osteoarthritis without pain is not affecting long-term mortality. More research is needed to understand how people adapt to knee pain, and how this leads to cardiovascular impairment,” said lead author Stefan Kluzek, PhD, of the Arthritis Research UK Centre of Excellence for Sport, Exercise and Osteoarthritis at the University of Oxford.

Researchers did not examine the reasons for the higher death rate, but an earlier look at data from the Chingford study found that women with knee OA were more likely to have hypertension, raised blood glucose, and moderately raised serum cholesterol.

Osteoarthritis is a joint disorder that leads to thinning of cartilage and progressive joint damage. Knee osteoarthritis is quite common and affects over 250 million people worldwide. Nearly 40 percent of Americans over the age of 45 have some degree of knee OA, and those numbers are expected to grow as the population ages.