Survey Repudiates Canada’s Pain Care Policies   

By Dr. Lynn Webster, PNN columnist

A recent survey by the Chronic Pain Association of Canada (CPAC) demonstrates all too well that our Canadian neighbors are sharing in the misfortune of America’s man-made crisis in pain care.

The online survey was distributed to patients via social media during a two-month period in the summer of 2019. CPAC received 740 responses from all 10 provinces and the territory of Nunavut. Key findings add to the growing evidence that people in pain are suffering from policies aimed at reducing access to pain medication.

  • Almost two-thirds of respondents (64%) reported they have not had adequate pain control in the past two years

  • A similar number (66.2%) feel discriminated against and degraded because they require opiate medicines to cope with severe pain

  • A third of patients (33.5%) have either been abandoned by their doctors or their doctors have refused to continue prescribing for them

  • Close to half (47.8%) have been forced against their will to taper their doses

  • Nearly 45% either have deteriorated relations with their medical providers or no longer have a doctor

  • Almost 40% were not adequately treated for pain in emergency rooms


Substitutes for opiates have not helped. About 70% of patients surveyed say they are more disabled, can do less with their lives, and their quality of life has declined.

Desperate Solutions

Almost 40% of patients have considered suicide because of the increased pain, while 5.4% have actually attempted suicide. A third of respondents (33.5%) reported that they know of someone who did commit suicide because of increased pain.

One other “desperate solution” is that nearly 10% of patients have substituted dangerous street drugs for what they previously received as safe prescriptions. Nearly a third of respondents (30.8%) reported they know patients who are purchasing street drugs for this reason.

Based on these findings, CPAC Executive Director Barry Ulmer penned a letter to Canada's Minister of Health.

"I’m writing on the first day of Canada’s National Pain Week, when the country notes the tragedy of chronic pain, the right of all Canadians to have their pain relieved, and government’s obligation to ensure appropriate and timely care,” Ulmer wrote.

“Yet two million Canadians with ongoing pain serious enough to warrant treatment with opioid analgesics still suffer profoundly — and pointlessly — because federal policy dismisses their needs. In today’s opioid-averse regulatory climate, their access to care shrinks precipitously as Canada’s pain specialists vanish from practice, and especially from prescribing."

Ulmer's letter further describes how people in pain feel that they are being erroneously blamed for Canada’s overdose problem. Many are being forced to taper or discontinue their pain medications. 

The CPAC findings mirror the results of a U.S. survey by Pain News Network which was released on the third anniversary of the 2016 publication of the CDC opioid prescribing guideline.  

In a critique of Canada’s 2017 opioid guideline – which was modeled after the CDC’s -- the Canadian Family Physician reports the guideline has left the Canadian health care system unable to manage its high-dose opioid patients:  

“However well-meaning they are, the 2017 Canadian opioid prescribing guidelines were introduced to a health care system ill equipped to care for patients with chronic pain. 

Without a clear and implementable patient-oriented strategy, combined with universal training in safe and effective chronic pain and addiction management for all health care providers, well-meaning documents like the 2017 Canadian guidelines might inadvertently harm the very people they hope to help."

As in the U.S., Canadian doctors are refusing to prescribe the opioids that patients need and alternative treatments are insufficient. The pharmaceutical industry is being villainized and health care professionals who prescribe opioids are under pressure to inappropriately adhere to a one-size-fits-all solution for pain patients.  

It is understandable that politicians want to reduce the harm from inappropriate use of opioids, but it should not be at the expense of people in pain. This is a human rights issue that must not be ignored.   


Lynn R. Webster, MD, is a vice president of scientific affairs for PRA Health Sciences and consults with the pharmaceutical industry. He is author of the award-winning book, The Painful Truth,” and co-producer of the documentary,It Hurts Until You Die.”

You can find Lynn on Twitter: @LynnRWebsterMD.

Opinions expressed here are those of the author alone and do not reflect the views or policy of PRA Health Sciences or Pain News Network.

Chronic Pain Patients in Alberta Revolt

By Marvin Ross, Guest Columnist

Last week the Chronic Pain Association of Canada issued a press release calling upon the Alberta health minister to investigate the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Alberta (CPSA) for “its unwarranted and secret cautioning and sanctioning” of doctors who prescribe opioid medication.

The press release came after a public meeting of pain patients in Edmonton organized by the group Help Alberta's Pain. Numerous patients showed up to complain about the poor quality of pain care in Alberta.

The meeting was so successful that the organizer, Tracy Fosum, told me that more meetings are being arranged in Edmonton, Calgary, Sherwood Park, Lethbridge and one in Northern Alberta.

An estimated 1.25 million Albertans suffer from chronic pain and 125,000 have long used opiate analgesics in order to function. In March, an Edmonton pain practice shutdown, throwing nearly 1,000 of these patients out of care.  


“Thousands of Albertans with pain have lost specialist and primary care because the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Alberta has forced doctors to stop prescribing opiates. The province's pain specialists are retiring in large numbers, citing College intimidation,” Barry Ulmer, Executive Director of the Chronic Pain Association of Canada said in a statement.

In response, the CPSA issued a statement from Registrar Dr. Scott McLeod calling such claims “misinformation” and denying there was an exodus of pain physicians from the profession.   

“Many Albertans suffer with severe daily pain and need medical assistance to allow them to live productive lives with their family, friends and in the workplace. We understand the challenges these Albertans face and encourage physicians to work with their patients to find a sustainable solution,” McLeod said. “Responsible prescribing does not include abrupt discontinuation or tapering of opioids or abandoning patients who use opioids.”

McLeod said the CPSA has been successful in reducing overdoses and opioid prescriptions. Accidental overdose deaths in Alberta from prescription opioids have been cut in half, there has been a 20% decline in opioid prescribing since 2016, and 13% fewer patients received an opioid in 2018 compared to 2016.

Patients Denied Treatment

Tracy Fosum recently appeared on the Roy Green syndicated radio show to talk about her personal experiences as a long time chronic pain patient in Alberta. Suffering from what even I recognized as the classic signs of a heart attack, she went to a local Edmonton hospital. Staff were suspicious of Tracy because of her high opioid use and, after a cursory exam, suggested she go home and take some NSAIDs for what they decided were chest muscle spasms.

Later, Tracy went to another hospital emergency room, where she was forced to wait for six hours as, she contends, they mistook her for a drug seeking addict. While trying to convince them to do an EKG, she went into cardiac arrest and collapsed. Fortunately, Tracy survived but ended up with heart damage because she had to wait too long.

Meanwhile, the Ontario College of Physicians and Surgeons is in the process of revising their opioid prescribing guidelines. A new draft policy states: “Physicians must not taper patients inappropriately or arbitrarily. Physicians are reminded that it is not always possible or appropriate to taper below a specific dose, nor is it usually appropriate to suddenly or rapidly taper prescriptions.”

The proposed guideline also states that “arbitrarily refusing to prescribe these drugs in all cases and without consideration for the circumstances of the patient may lead to inadequate patient care.”

While this is a step in the right direction, the problem is that patients have little recourse other than filing a formal complaint if a doctor provides poor treatment. A formal complaint can take months to years to resolve and ruins a doctor/patient relationship.

I am personally familiar with one case where a chronic pain patient was refused care by a doctor unless she agreed not to take any opioid medication. That doctor was sanctioned for refusing a patient on narcotics and refusing to prescribe narcotics, but the sanction was simply “Don't do that. You cannot refuse.” That patient now has no doctor because no one will take her on.

The Colleges can revise their rules and recommendations all they want, but they also need to ensure that doctors adhere to them.


Marvin Ross is a medical writer and publisher in Dundas, Ontario. He is a regular contributor to the Huffington Post.

The information in this column should not be considered as professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. It is for informational purposes only and represents the author’s opinions alone. It does not inherently express or reflect the views, opinions and/or positions of Pain News Network.