Arthritis Pain Varies Widely Across States
/By Pat Anson, PNN Editor
People living in West Virginia are three times more likely to have moderate or severe joint pain from arthritis than those in Minnesota, according to a comprehensive new study that highlights how disparities in education and access to social services contribute to chronic pain.
“Very little research has examined the geography of chronic pain, and virtually none has examined the role of state-level policies in shaping pain prevalence,” says co-author Hanna Grol-Prokopczyk, PhD, an associate professor of sociology at the University of Buffalo. “We were excited to identify state characteristics that reduce residents’ risk of pain.”
Grol-Prokopczyk and her colleagues looked at data for over 400,000 adults who participated in the 2017 Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System, along with data from all 50 states on social assistance and anti-poverty programs such as the Earned Income Tax Credit, Medicaid and Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), more commonly known as food stamps.
Their findings, published in the journal PAIN, show the risk of joint pain was significantly higher in states in Appalachia, the Mississippi Valley and the South, compared to states in the Upper Midwest and West.
Nearly one in four adults in West Virginia (23.1%), Alabama (21.6%) and Arkansas (21.4%) had moderate to severe joint pain. States with the lowest risk of joint pain are Minnesota (6.9%), Hawaii (7.5%) and Utah (7.7%).
Digging deeper into the data, researchers found that educational disparities are also associated with pain frequency. People who did not complete high school in West Virginia (31.1%), Arkansas (29.7%) and Alabama (28.3%) were far more likely to have joint pain compared to those with bachelor degrees in California (8.8%), Nevada (9.8%) and Utah (10.1%).
People with less education are more likely to have blue-collar jobs requiring manual labor that may contribute to joint pain. They also have lower incomes and less access to healthcare.
“Education can function as a ‘personal firewall’ that protects more highly educated people from undesirable state-level contexts, while increasing the vulnerability of less educated individuals,” said first author Rui Huang, a sociology PhD student in the UB College of Arts and Sciences.
Researchers also found that states with higher levels of SNAP benefits, social support and community health services had lower levels of pain frequency.
“The increase in the generosity of SNAP benefits could potentially alleviate pain by promoting healthier eating habits and alleviating the life stress associated with food insecurity,” says Huang. “Social factors such as conflict, isolation and devaluation are also among the ‘social threats’ that can lead to physical reactions such as inflammation and immune system changes.”
Previous studies at the University of Buffalo have found that gender, poverty and education play a role in pain frequency and that the overall prevalence of pain is increasing in the United States, affecting virtually every age group, sex, ethnicity and demographic.